I never liked the sound of bagpipes. So miserable and whiney. I was intrigued by the news that a "man with a Scottish accent and wearing Hibernian Football Club shorts took [his bagpipes] out of his car and knelt down to play loudly in the faces of the [Insulate Britain] protesters. According to telegraph.co.uk 'He said: “They are holding up ambulances, fire trucks. Disgraceful. You're damaging your cause. What I was doing, obnoxiously, bagpiping in your face, is what you're doing to all this traffic - you're obnoxiously holding up people's lives."'
Rumours that the man was Alistair Campbell were denied by friends of the New Labour spin doctor who said "Alistair would never kneel to anyone".
The protesters were blocking the A40 but started their campaign by doing so on and around the M25. Which is why, when I next go to Kent, I shall be taking my trumpet with me. I reckon I can make more frightening noise than a bagpiper although, given it will be more pleasant, I might just gain a rapt audience.
I felt I should at least find out what Insulate Britain's aims are. They have two simple "demands":
1. That the UK government immediately promises to fully fund and take responsibility for the insulation of all social housing in Britain by 2025;
2. That the UK government immediately promises to produce within four months a legally binding national plan to fully fund and take responsibility for the full low-energy and low-carbon whole-house retrofit, with no externalised costs, of all homes in Britain by 2030 as part of a just transition to full decarbonisation of all parts of society and the economy.
On the face of it these seem entirely reasonable. IB's analysis is robust:
The UK has some 29 million homes and they are the oldest and least energy efficient housing stock in Europe. Every year vast amounts of precious energy are wasted in heating and, increasingly, cooling our buildings.
In order to meet UK commitments under the Paris Agreement to stay below 1.5C, and legal obligations under the Climate Change Act 2008, as amended in 2019, emissions from heating and powering homes must be reduced by 78% in less than 15 years and then to zero by 2050.
Nearly 15% of the UK’s total emissions comes from heating homes: an overhaul of the energy performance of the UK’s housing stock is needed to reduce the energy demand.
So is the government not interested in this issue? I guess it's the sheer scale and cost of it. The Green Homes Grant scheme was discontinued after just six months but there are still home energy grants such as the Warm Home Discount but this is applied as a rebate to your electricity bills - unless, of course, your supplier has recently gone bust. Reasonably, the discount prioritises vulnerable people and others in need. I think the government is committed to home insulation as one of the means of moving towards carbon neutrality, but there is a vast space between the government's fiscal means, its pace of change and Insulate Britain's "do it sooner" demands.
As with many protest movements, the drastic tactics of Insulate Britain - an offshoot of Extinction Rebellion - are designed to draw attention to the cause (surely a worthy one) at the risk of alienating the public opinion that is eventually necessary to give the government a shot in the arm. Guerrilla tactics are no substitute for a mass movement; indeed, they may hinder that very swelling of public opinion that should be the ultimate goal.
Early next month I'll probably be in my (diesel😠sorry IB!) car on the M25. If I meet them, I'll get my trumpet out and attempt a deal with the protesters: "I'll play you the whole of the Trumpet Voluntary if you let me (oh and maybe my fellow drivers) go on our merry way".
Think it'll work?